HOA Detective™ – Feb 21, 2025: In April 2023, the residents of the Majestic Isle Condominium in North Bay Village, Florida, faced an unexpected and urgent crisis: their home was declared structurally unsafe, necessitating immediate evacuation. This event not only disrupted the lives of approximately 55 residents, but also highlighted broader issues related to building safety, aging infrastructure, and the complexities of urban redevelopment. Below is a timeline of events since this story was first reported.
April 14, 2023: Initial Inspection and Discovery – The sequence of events began on April 14, 2023, when a building engineer conducted a 60-year recertification inspection of the Majestic Isle Condominium, located at 7946 East Drive. This routine inspection was intended to assess the building’s structural integrity, as mandated by local regulations for aging structures. During the assessment, the engineer identified significant concerns, including sagging floors and extensive termite damage. These issues raised immediate red flags about the building’s safety and habitability.
https://northbayvillage-fl.gov/majestic-isle-residents/
Mid-April 2023: Partial Ceiling Collapse – Compounding these structural concerns, a leak from a roof drain led to a partial ceiling collapse in several units during the same week. This incident prompted the evacuation of residents from five units, reducing the number of occupied units to 31 out of the total 36. The combination of the engineer’s findings and the ceiling collapse underscored the severity of the building’s deterioration.
April 19, 2023: Official Notification – On the night of April 19, 2023, North Bay Village officials received a detailed report from the building engineer outlining the critical structural issues. The report’s alarming conclusions prompted immediate action from the village authorities to safeguard the well-being of the residents.
April 20, 2023: Evacuation Order Issued – The following day, April 20, 2023, village officials went door-to-door informing residents that the Majestic Isle Condominium had been deemed structurally unsafe. An evacuation order was issued, requiring all residents to vacate the premises by 10 a.m. on April 25, 2023. This five-day window was provided to allow residents time to arrange alternative accommodations and begin the process of relocating their belongings.
April 20, 2023: Emergency Meeting and Support Initiatives – On the evening of April 20, 2023, an emergency meeting was convened in the parking lot of the condominium. Village officials, alongside representatives from agencies such as the Miami-Dade County Office of Housing Advocacy and the Homeless Trust, were present to address residents’ concerns and provide assistance to the displaced unit owners. Discussions focused on immediate housing solutions, financial aid, and the logistics of the evacuation process. The village also established a fund to accept donations for displaced families and compiled a list of available rental units in the area to facilitate swift relocation.
April 25, 2023: Deadline for Evacuation – By the morning of April 25, 2023, the evacuation was completed. Residents had spent the intervening days packing essential belongings and securing temporary housing. The North Bay Village Police Department oversaw the move-out process, implementing a staggered schedule to ensure safety and order. While residents were permitted to take essential items, arrangements were made for them to return later to retrieve remaining possessions once the building’s status was further assessed.
May 2023: Initial Discussions on Building’s Future – In the weeks following the evacuation, discussions emerged regarding the future of the Majestic Isle Condominium. Given the building’s significant structural issues and the financial implications of necessary repairs, stakeholders, including the condominium association and potential developers, began exploring options. These discussions were in the preliminary stages, with no definitive plans announced.
May 2024: Acquisition by Developers – A year later, in May 2024, significant developments occurred concerning the property. The Related Group, in partnership with New York-based Macklowe Properties, acquired 14 units within the Majestic Isle Condominium for approximately $7.9 million. This purchase brought their total ownership to 20 out of the 36 units. The developers also owned the adjacent Biscayne Sea Club property, which they had purchased for $47.7 million in 2023. These acquisitions were part of a strategic plan to amass a substantial waterfront assemblage for a proposed luxury residential development.
December 2024: Legislative Changes Impacting Condominiums – By December 2024, broader legislative changes in Florida began to impact condominium associations statewide. In response to incidents like the Surfside collapse and the evacuation of buildings such as the Majestic Isle, Florida lawmakers enacted regulations requiring more rigorous structural inspections and mandating that associations maintain adequate reserve funds for repairs. These laws aimed to prevent future crises, but also placed financial pressures on older condominium communities, potentially accelerating trends toward redevelopment.
February 2025: Current Status – As of February 2025, the Majestic Isle Condominium remains uninhabited. The developers, having acquired most of the units, are in the process of finalizing plans for the new luxury residential project that will encompass both the Majestic Isle and Biscayne Sea Club properties. Former residents have largely resettled, though some continue to navigate the complexities of relocation and compensation. The situation underscores the challenges faced by aging infrastructures in coastal regions and the delicate balance between ensuring public safety and addressing the housing needs of long-standing communities.
The Majestic Isle incident serves as a poignant example of the multifaceted issues surrounding building maintenance, resident displacement, and urban redevelopment. It highlights the necessity for proactive infrastructure assessments, the importance of supportive measures for displaced individuals, and the ongoing dialogue required between communities and developers to navigate the future of urban living spaces.
Fortunately for the unit owners at Majestic Isle Condominium, there was a White Knight in the form of The Related Group et al, who were willing and able to purchase the dilapidated units. Not all condominiums will be so lucky in the future.
Because You’re Buying More Than a Home!
