HOA Detective | October 31, 2025: In physics, inertia describes an object’s tendency to keep doing whatever it is already doing – whether moving or standing still – until some external force compels it to change. In the world of homeowner associations (HOAs), there is a similar phenomenon at work, though it plays out in budgets rather than in motion. We refer to these somewhat unique phenomena as “financial inertia” – the ability of an HOA to keep operating, sometimes long after sound fiscal principles have failed – because it possesses a unique power most private organizations never have: the legal authority to compel revenue.
Levy Power: Every HOA has the power to levy assessments. These assessments may be called dues, maintenance fees, or common charges, but their function is identical to that of a property tax. They are mandatory, recurring, and enforceable through lien and foreclosure. When viewed through this lens, the HOA begins to look less like a small nonprofit and more like a micro-municipality – one that collects taxes, maintains public works, and governs a defined territory. And like governments, HOAs benefit from a kind of built-in financial momentum. HOA assessments are:
- Mandatory;
- Recurring;
- Enforceable through lien and foreclosure.
This is where financial inertia enters the picture. The HOA’s taxing authority creates a steady inflow of cash that cushions the organization against the consequences of mismanagement. It allows an association to operate at a deficit, to defer maintenance, or even to make poor financial decisions year after year without immediate collapse. The bills still get paid – at least for a while – because the revenue stream is legally guaranteed.
A government can run a deficit, as we all know; a large corporation can carry long-term debt. An HOA can do both in miniature—because its members are legally bound to fund its operations no matter how inefficient they become.
Implications of Financial Inertia: When a corporation fails, investors lose their capital. When a city goes bankrupt, citizens lose services and face emergency taxes. But when an HOA’s governance model fails, every owner becomes the lender of last resort. The Association’s debts and deferred obligations ultimately fall on the collective shoulders of its members. Whether through special assessments, emergency loans, or skyrocketing dues, the financial inertia that once sustained the HOA’s operations eventually turns into an anchor dragging the entire community down.
Double-Edged Sword: This financial inertia can be both stabilizing and dangerous. On the one hand, it provides continuity – roads are maintained, insurance is renewed, and the lights stay on even when leadership falters. On the other hand, it enables complacency. A board that knows it can always raise assessments may not feel the urgency to plan responsibly or build long-term reserves. Managers accustomed to predictable revenue inflows can ignore structural deficits for years. By the time the financial reckoning arrives, the numbers are often worse than anyone imagined.
After analyzing HOA financial data from across the country for almost fifteen years, the Detective and his partners at CIDAnalytics have seen this pattern repeat countless times. Associations drift into insolvency not through sudden catastrophe, but through slow erosion – maintenance postponed, reserves underfunded, and audits neglected. Eventually, things get so bad that the only way out is a massive bank loan with a payback period that now stretches to the middle of the 21st century, in many instances.
Familiar Warning Signs: Rising delinquency rates, aging infrastructure, deferred maintenance, and a growing gap between reserve contributions and actual repair costs are common signs of an HOA that is experiencing the negative impact of financial inertia. Yet because the Association continues to collect assessments, it rarely experiences the sort of existential crisis that might otherwise force reform.
What makes this dynamic particularly insidious is that it hides behind the language of “community.” Owners think of their dues as supporting shared interests, not underwriting risk. But in truth, every payment reinforces the Association’s financial inertia. It sustains an organization that may be functioning well below the standards of fiscal prudence that any city, corporation, or family would consider acceptable.
Financial Inertia at Government Scale: Governments are not immune to this inertia either. Municipalities can carry unfunded pension obligations or deferred infrastructure maintenance for decades. Large corporations can leverage debt and continue paying dividends even as their balance sheets deteriorate. But HOAs occupy a unique space between the public and private spheres. They have the coercive power of taxation without the accountability mechanisms of government, and they possess the profit immunity of nonprofits without the transparency requirements imposed on charities. Legally and financially speaking, HOAs are a structural hybrid organizational format that allows inefficiency to persist unchecked for astonishingly long periods. Financial inertia explains why some HOAs persist long after they should have collapsed under their own mismanagement. It explains why owners often discover, too late, that the Association has been running on fumes. The machine keeps moving until it hits the wall – and when it does, everyone is strapped inside. The power to levy assessments ensures the HOA can always reach into its members’ pockets to fill the gap, no matter how deep.
The lesson for homeowners and boards alike is that solvency is not the same as fiscal health. A community can appear financially stable while still operating in structural deficit. True fiscal health requires more than the ability to collect dues –
it requires disciplined planning, reserve adequacy, transparent accounting, and a culture of long-term thinking. Otherwise, financial inertia will keep the organization coasting forward – right up until the moment gravity reasserts itself.
Sobering Takeaway for Homeowners: As vested stakeholders (this means you), HOA members are the financial backstop. Every dollar not saved today becomes your future obligation. Every year without a reserve study, every deferred audit, every ignored warning from a contractor or engineer adds mass to the problem. The HOA’s financial inertia buys time, but it also compounds risk. And when that risk finally comes due, there’s no bailout – just a bill with your name on it.
By Definition: Inertia resists change. Understanding this sobering reality is the first step toward overcoming it. For HOAs, that means acknowledging the seductive comfort of a guaranteed revenue stream and choosing to act before necessity forces your hand. The most responsible communities are those that learn to use their financial inertia not as a crutch, but as a stabilizing force – one that allows them to plan, save, and invest in their own sustainability. In the end, an HOA without financial momentum is an organization without direction. A sailboat adrift, heading for a near-certain collision.
Because You’re Buying More Than a Home!
