HOA Detective™ – Jan 17, 2025: In the realm of HOA due diligence, understanding the financial dynamics of community associations is paramount. A concept that illustrates one of the most difficult challenges faced by many associations is the “Lafayette Syndrome.”
The term Lafayette Syndrome, (coined by CIDAnalytics (CIDA), encapsulates a critical fiscal issue confronting municipalities, homeowner associations (HOAs), and condominium communities across the United States and Canada. This phenomenon describes situations where current revenues are insufficient to allow for the accumulation of replacement reserves that will be required in the future to pay for major maintenance and replacement of infrastructure and building assets for which the organization is responsible for maintaining.
The Lafayette Syndrome gets its name from the 2015 Urban3 case study of Lafayette, Louisiana. The landmark study serves as a poignant illustration of this issue, revealing that future capital expenditures required to maintain municipally-owned infrastructure would be six times more than the property taxes paid by the average homeowner over the life of the infrastructure assets.
https://www.urbanthree.com/case-study/lafayette-la/
Urban3’s Lafayette Case Study
Urban3’s analysis in Lafayette highlighted a significant imbalance between municipal revenues and expenditures. The study employed a Cost-of-Service analysis to model municipal cash flow across the parish, revealing that many properties generated less tax revenue than the cost of services they consumed. This fiscal disparity indicated that the city’s development patterns were financially unsustainable, with sprawling suburban areas failing to generate sufficient revenue to cover their infrastructure maintenance costs.
The study’s visualizations depict parcels subject to property taxation as net positive parcels in (black, rising above the ground), and net negative parcels in (red, sinking down below the ground). The graphic effectively illustrates the areas where the city was financially gaining at the time of the study (circa 2015).
One striking finding was that the total capital revenue in 2015 was significantly lower than the projected 50-year cost of maintaining roads, underscoring the impending fiscal shortfall.
Parallels in Other Municipalities
Lafayette’s situation is not unique. Many American cities face similar challenges due to decades of unproductive growth and suburban sprawl. A 2020 analysis by Strong Towns emphasized that poor neighborhoods often yield higher returns on public investment compared to affluent suburban areas, primarily because the infrastructure costs in dense urban neighborhoods are lower relative to the tax revenue they generate.
https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2020/11/11/poor-neighborhoods-make-the-best-investments-md2020
Additionally, a 2018 article from Strong Towns discussed how cities’ financial struggles are exacerbated by development patterns that prioritize short-term growth over long-term fiscal sustainability. The piece argued that many municipalities have accumulated extensive infrastructure liabilities without corresponding revenue streams, leading to chronic budget deficits.
Challenges in Homeowner Associations and Condominiums
The Lafayette Syndrome extends beyond municipal governments to HOAs and condominium associations, many of which are now managing properties over 30 years old. Aging infrastructure in these communities presents significant financial challenges, particularly when adequate reserve funds have not been established for major maintenance and repairs or actual replacement of community-maintained assets.
A 2023 article from Property Management Inc. highlighted that many HOAs encounter problems due to aging infrastructure, often resorting to temporary fixes due to insufficient funding, which can lead to more costly repairs in the long run.
Furthermore, a 2024 report from East Coast Water Quality discussed the widespread issue of aging water infrastructure in the U.S., noting that many communities, including HOAs, struggle with financial constraints and the growing need for infrastructure overhauls.
https://eastcoastwaterquality.com/news/americas-aging-water-infrastructure-crisis/
Exacerbating Factors: Rising Operating Costs
The financial strain on municipalities and HOAs is further intensified by escalating operating costs, particularly for utilities and insurance. A 2025 article from the HOA Detective™ reported that HOAs and property owners nationwide are facing a significant crisis due to rapidly increasing property insurance costs. This surge is largely attributed to increased losses from natural disasters over the past decade, leading many associations to raise annual dues or levy special assessments to cover the additional expenses.
CIDAnalytics and the “2020 HOA Tipping Point”
CIDAnalytics has been at the forefront of addressing these challenges since 2010, when its founders introduced the concept of an impending “HOA Tipping Point.” They predicted that by around 2020, a significant number of HOAs would face financial difficulties due to aging infrastructure and inadequate reserve funds. This foresight has proven accurate, as many associations now grapple with the compounded issues of deteriorating assets and rising maintenance costs.
Champlain Tower
The 6/24/2021 collapse of the Champlain Tower South Condominium in Surfside, FL serves as a tragic footnote of the CIDA 2020 HOA Tipping Point thesis first introduced more than a decade before the collapse. Considering what we now know about the underlying causes of the ill-fated building’s collapse, it can be said that this horrific event was entirely preventable.
Lack of adequate funds after a 2018 engineering report identified major structural issues with the building, led to inaction by the buildings’ ownership, while local building officials took a collective “head in the sand” approach to dealing with the problematic building.
In effect, the collapse of Champlain Tower was the equivalent of “pilot error” when a plane crash results in the death of 98 passengers and crew.
The collapse resulted in 98 human fatalities, property damage losses estimated to be $200M, and liability claims which now exceed $1B as of the end of 2024. This catastrophic tragedy was largely the result of the building owners failure to accumulate sufficient funds to pay for critical repairs over the 40+ years since the building was constructed. The collapse is nothing less than a horrific example that underscores a core tenet of the Lafayette Syndrome.
https://apnews.com/article/florida-condo-association-cost-increase-62de80fcc5de498309d9fea2b78a2984
HOAs Face Financial Strain Amid Rising Costs
Conclusion
The Lafayette Syndrome underscores a pervasive issue affecting municipalities and community associations nationwide: the failure to align current revenues with future infrastructure liabilities. The case of Lafayette, Louisiana, serves as a cautionary tale, illustrating the dire consequences of unbalanced development and inadequate financial planning. In short, the Lafayette Syndrome suggests the financial model used by many HOAs, and condominium associations will not result in economically sustainable communities beyond 50 years.
To mitigate these challenges, it is imperative for governing bodies to adopt proactive asset management strategies, prioritize sustainable development patterns, and establish sufficient reserve funds to ensure the long-term viability of their communities.
Because You’re Buying More Than a Home!
